Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Medawar's avatar

The reliance on fallacy and attempts to promote assertion over evidence seem to go back at least as far as the founding of something called "The X Club" in the 19th century, which involved a group of largely mediocre scientists from both sides of the Atlantic who disliked the fact that a lot of useful science was being done, for nothing, by clergymen in their spare time, rather than having the church and the taxpayer hand money over to a new class of professional scientists (members of the X Club, in other words.)

Members of the X Club helped each other rise to positions of influence mainly by marking each other's homework rather than by doing lots of groundbreaking work, and because the X Club did very little else other than promote the status of its members, they ended up controlling the flow of taxpayer's and charitable monies to the new class of professional scientists. In order to eliminate the hateful amateur scientists (many of them Christian clergy) they also concocted the "conflict thesis" which held that faith and science were both opposites and enemies and that throughout history faith has tried to suppress science and perpetrate ignorance. There are an awful lot of very famous examples of the church persecuting scientists and suppressing important discoveries throughout history as it is now taught, the only snag being that even the really key examples of Galileo and Copernicus are not, in fact, as they are currently taught when the actual historical source material is referred to!

Every school child in the UK is taught, and firmly believes, that when Christians were in charge the streets were knee-deep in excrement and nobody washed. Almost every intellectual adult in the Kingdom will quote this as fact, but it isn't. Prior to the advent of synthetic phosphate and nitrate fertilizers, dung was too valuable not to be collected and put on the fields!

The fallacies we are being fed over covid and the pandemic, are supported on a much deeper foundation of lies which deny that past scientific progress (which has been demonstrably slowing down since the 1970s if not before) depended on evidence-based argument and the TESTING of ideas, which Christianity, far from suppressing, actually encouraged by developing and teaching the skills of theological argument.

There is a very good book on this:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Popes-Unicorns-Science-Christianity-Conflict/dp/0190053097

and this book, by Dr Clare Craig, shows not only that this sort of deception is still ongoing in the twenty-first century, but that to some extent even Dr Craig has brought into the core falsehood that faith and science are mutually exclusive.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Expired-untold-Dr-Clare-Craig/dp/1739344707

That's not to say that what she writes is wrong or needs to be disregarded: rather it proves how deeply certain pernicious falsehoods have been embedded into intellectual minds and not just the minds of the masses.

It may be significant that Elon Musk chose to rebrand Twitter as "X", perhaps in homage to the anti-scientists of the X Club?

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts